I'm Not That Girl by Idina Menzel cover art

Similar songs playlist

Songs Like I'm Not That Girl

by Idina Menzel · Wicked (Original Broadway Cast Recording)

49 songs 2 hr 45 min of full-length music

Looking for songs like I'm Not That Girl by Idina Menzel? Here are 49 similar songs, starting with As Long As You're Mine by Idina Menzel, I’m Not That Girl by Cynthia Erivo and Popular by Kristin Chenoweth. Unlike preview-only playlist generators, every track here plays in full. Press play and the playlist keeps going on its own.

Similar songs to I'm Not That Girl by Idina Menzel

1
As Long As You're MineIdina Menzel
3:46
2
I’m Not That GirlCynthia Erivo
3:58
3
PopularKristin Chenoweth
3:45
4
ReflectionLea Salonga
2:27
5
Colors of the WindJudy Kuhn
3:35
6
You'll Be In My HeartGlenn Close
1:37
7
Defying GravityKristin Chenoweth
5:54
8
Beauty and the BeastAngela Lansbury
2:43
9
Part Of Your World (The Little Mermaid)【Anna】Annapantsu
3:16
10
I Will Always Love YouDolly Parton
2:57
11
For GoodKristin Chenoweth
5:07
12
Never EnoughLoren Allred
3:28
13
Journey to the PastChristy Altomare
3:17
14
I See the Light (From "Tangled" / Soundtrack Version)Mandy Moore
3:45
15
No Good DeedIdina Menzel
3:32
16
My Heart Will Go On (Love Theme from "Titanic")Céline Dion
4:40
17
A Sentimental ManJoel Grey
1:17
18
I’m Not That Girl (Reprise)Ariana Grande
2:11
19
The Wizard And ICarole Shelley
5:10
20
A Million DreamsZiv Zaifman
4:30
21
I Just Can't Wait to Be KingJason Weaver
2:51
22
She Used to Be MineJessie Mueller
4:21
23
Part of Your World (Reprise II)Halle
1:34
24
A Whole New WorldMena Massoud
2:56
25
Can You Feel the Love TonightJoseph Williams
2:58
26
Ozdust Duet (Bonus Track)The Wicked Orchestra
2:12
27
No One Is AlonePhillipa Soo
3:44
28
I Will Always Love YouWhitney Houston
4:24
29
On My OwnSamantha Barks
3:12
30
A Whole New WorldLea Salonga
2:41
31
How Far I'll GoJanella Salvador
2:48
32
HallelujahTori Kelly
3:28
33
On My OwnFrances Ruffelle
4:12
34
Dear TheodosiaLeslie Odom Jr.
3:05
35
What Is This Feeling?Kristin Chenoweth
3:33
36
A Sentimental ManJeff Goldblum
2:13
37
Mother Knows Best (From "Tangled"/Soundtrack Version)Donna Murphy
3:11
38
Once Upon a DecemberChristy Altomare
3:00
39
One Short DayKristin Chenoweth
3:04
40
Seasons of Love (From the Motion Picture RENT)Cast Of Rent
3:03
41
Memory (Radio Edit)Elaine Paige
4:17
42
Part of Your WorldJodi Benson
3:16
43
Finale "Wicked"Kristin Chenoweth
1:42
44
Journey to the Past (From The "Anastasia" Soundtrack)Liz Callaway
2:56
45
Love Is an Open Door (From "Frozen"/Soundtrack Version)Kristen Bell
2:05
46
Heart of Stone (feat. Natalie Paris)SIX
5:12
47
Dancing Through LifeNorbert Leo Butz
7:38
48
Belle (Reprise)Emma Watson
1:16
49
SomewhereRita Moreno
3:11

Questions about songs like I'm Not That Girl

What songs are similar to I'm Not That Girl by Idina Menzel?

Songs similar to I'm Not That Girl include "As Long As You're Mine" by Idina Menzel, "I’m Not That Girl" by Cynthia Erivo, "Popular" by Kristin Chenoweth, "Reflection" by Lea Salonga and "Colors of the Wind" by Judy Kuhn. The full playlist above has 49 songs like I'm Not That Girl, and you can play every one of them in full for free.

Which artists sound like Idina Menzel?

If you like Idina Menzel, try Cynthia Erivo, Kristin Chenoweth, Lea Salonga, Judy Kuhn, Glenn Close and Angela Lansbury. They all appear in this playlist of songs like I'm Not That Girl.

Can I listen to songs like I'm Not That Girl for free?

Yes. Every song on this page plays in full through YouTube's player, right here on the page. There are no 30-second previews and you don't need a Spotify account or any sign-up.

How is this list of similar songs made?

We start from I'm Not That Girl by Idina Menzel and pull the tracks that listeners most often play next on YouTube Music. Songs that share its mood, genre and audience rise to the top. Click any title to get songs like that track instead.